CLEAR SCORECARD · SAMPLE
Harbor Street Plumbing (fictional)
All criteria rated
| Pillar | Score | Summary |
|---|---|---|
| CClarity | 13 /20 | Services are clear on the website; service area and next steps are inconsistent across pages. |
| LListings | 10 /20 | Phone number differs on two of six listings; holiday hours missing on Google and Apple Maps. |
| EEvidence | 12 /20 | Strong recent Google reviews; website testimonials are from 2019 with no permission record. |
| AAnswerability | 14 /20 | Good FAQ; the contact form sends to an inbox that is checked weekly. |
| RResilience | 9 /20 | Domain registered to the former web designer; one admin on the Google profile; two-step off. |
How scoring works
Each pillar has five criteria, and each criterion is rated from 0 to 4 against documented evidence, for a pillar score out of 20 and a total out of 100. If any criterion cannot be rated, for example because access was not provided, it is marked not rated, never scored as zero, and the /100 total is withheld so the score does not imply complete coverage.
The score is a baseline for tracking progress. It is not a ranking forecast, certification, or guarantee of results.
| When | Pillar | Action |
|---|---|---|
| Now | R | Transfer the domain to a business-owned registrar account and turn on automatic renewal. |
| Now | L | Correct the phone number on Yelp and Bing Places; add holiday hours to Google and Apple Maps. |
| Now | R | Add a second owner to the Google Business Profile and turn on two-step verification. |
| Next | E | Replace 2019 testimonials with current ones collected with written permission. |
| Next | C | Add a service-area page and state the next step on every service page. |
| Later | A | Route the contact form to a monitored inbox and set a one-business-day reply standard. |
| Ref | Observation | Source | Date |
|---|---|---|---|
| L-03 | Yelp listing shows (414) 555-0148; website and Google show (414) 555-0190. | Yelp business page, screenshot | Oct 6 |
| E-02 | Three website testimonials dated 2019; no permission record provided. | Website /reviews page; intake response | Oct 6 |
| R-01 | Registrar contact is a former vendor’s email address. | Owner-provided registrar screen, view only | Oct 7 |
Limitations noted
- Social accounts were reviewed for business facts only; content and engagement were outside scope.
- Phone and email response times were tested once and may vary.
Phone numbers above use the fictional 555 range. A real scorecard includes the full set of findings, evidence references, and limitations, and is discussed in a 60-minute readout.